10 Best Mountain Bike Shoes 2025 in the United States

The SHIMANO Unisex's Biking Cycling Shoe is a versatile option designed for a variety of off-road cycling activities. One of its standout features is the SPD cleat compatibility, making it suitable for most clip-in pedal systems. The sole is made of grippy rubber, which is beneficial for both stable pedaling and walking, although it might not offer the stiffest sole for hardcore mountain bikers seeking maximum power transfer.

The shoe's single strap closure system is easy to use and provides a snug fit, but it may not be as customizable or secure as multi-strap or BOA systems. Constructed from synthetic leather and mesh, the shoe is designed for durability and protection, promising long-lasting performance. However, the breathability might be a concern for some users in hotter conditions due to the synthetic materials.

The shoe is easy to maintain as it’s machine washable, which is a plus for busy cyclists. Comfort-wise, the fit is generally good, though some may find it less comfortable for longer rides or extreme weather conditions. In summary, the SHIMANO Unisex's Biking Cycling Shoe is a solid choice for recreational and intermediate mountain bikers looking for a durable and versatile shoe with good pedal compatibility and a secure fit, though it may not meet the needs of more demanding riders in terms of sole stiffness and advanced closure systems.

The Giro Tracker Men BOA mountain bike shoe is designed mainly for riders using flat pedals, including e-bike riders, making it a solid choice for all-day trail adventures. Its sole features a full-length molded Tack rubber outsole with deep lugs that offer strong grip and durability on various terrains, although it doesn't emphasize stiffness which is more important for clip-in pedal users. The twin BOA L6 dials provide a very precise and easy closure system, allowing quick micro-adjustments and a secure fit.

Comfort-wise, the shoe uses breathable mesh fabric combined with Thermobonded PU reinforcements at the toe and heel, balancing durability with ventilation. Added cushioning comes from a dual-layer EVA midsole and a medium arch support footbed, providing support for long rides without feeling too stiff or heavy. Protection is decent due to reinforced areas at the toe and heel, shielding against abrasion during rough rides. These shoes are not compatible with clip-in pedals, limiting them to flat pedal riders.

While weather resistance is not explicitly highlighted, making them less ideal for very wet or cold conditions, the Giro Tracker offers a durable, comfortable flat-pedal shoe with excellent grip and easy adjustability for trail riding. It is a dependable option for those prioritizing comfort and protection over maximum stiffness or clip-in compatibility.

The Giro Tracker mountain bike shoes offer a solid performance with a few standout features. The BOA L6 Dial closure system with stainless steel laces ensures a secure and adjustable fit, making them convenient for quick adjustments while on the trail. The Tack Rubber outsole with a dual-layer EVA and Gamma tread design provides excellent grip on flat pedals, making them ideal for riders who prefer not to use cleats. The shoe's textile upper with Thermo-bonded PU overlays adds durability and protection against rough terrain.

Additionally, the shoes are relatively lightweight at 337 grams, which is a plus for long rides. However, one potential drawback is the lack of cleat compatibility, limiting options for riders who might want to switch to clip-in pedals. While the textile upper contributes to breathability, the weather resistance might not be sufficient for very wet conditions.

The die-cut footbed offers some comfort, but riders seeking extra cushioning or arch support might need to look elsewhere. These shoes are well-suited for flat pedal mountain bikers who value a secure fit and good pedal grip.